Common Sense

Clan Forum
 
HomePortalFAQSearchMemberlistRegisterLog in
Clan Pages
 About Common Sense
 How to Join
 Trophy Hall
League Season 4
Status: ended
Articles
Play Testing
Find play testers and see the play test guantlet here

Share | 
 

 League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format

View previous topic View next topic Go down 

Would you play Pauper Starter Deck as a league format?
Yes
25%
 25% [ 1 ]
No
75%
 75% [ 3 ]
Total Votes : 4
 

AuthorMessage
JMason
Admin
Admin


Posts : 490
Join date : 2008-12-08
Location : Coventry

PostSubject: League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format   Fri Jan 30, 2009 8:59 am

I disagreed with the decision to ban slivers from the league. The result has not been a clear field, instead the next best tribe has dominated. I know some players have been unhappy that their decks are not competitive.
I am proposing a different idea for the next league. Something more like core set starter deck format. "Pauper starter deck" would be a format where you could choose one of five mono colour pauper decks to play. The five deck lists would be pre-agreed, be as equal as we can make them, and not use any unduly expensive or hard to get cards, so no lightning bolt, counterspell, gush etc.

The results would then reflect play ability ove rdeck design.

Would you play that format?
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Mooncalf
Master Sorcerer
avatar

Posts : 115
Join date : 2008-06-09
Age : 38
Location : The Netherlands

PostSubject: Re: League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format   Sun Feb 01, 2009 8:10 am

To be honest this seems like a really dull format to me.

Like in this tribal format its like (estimated)

-25% deckbuilding skills
-25% metagame knowledge (will i play elves vs player A, or monoblack zombies vs player A, will i sneak in some hexhunters in my elvesdeck when i suspect someone playing white or favor/clout/oversoul, if i suspect alot of spells in the metagame which do 1-3 dmg, will i try to put x/4(+) creatures in my deck, etc)
-25% playing skill
-25% luck

take away the first two and you will end up with 25% playing skill and 75% luck.

also i dont think only 1 tribe dominates the current league. Look at andy he has played more than 4 different decks (tribes) i think and he has won almost all his matches.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
timmyhill
Moderator
Moderator


Posts : 184
Join date : 2008-06-07
Location : buffalo ny

PostSubject: Re: League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format   Sun Feb 01, 2009 4:52 pm

my two sense is at first i wasnt really thrilled with tribal but i do like it. i think limiting slives wasnt enough, i had guessed elves would make a strong showing but i never realized they would be so strong.

i have always been intrested in mirror match ups so some kind of "starter" deck round does sound intresting but i have to agree witn mooncalf most of the games would come down to who got the better draw. as a long time vintage player i've seen this happen many times were the winner is simply the player who wins the dice roll and gets to go first.

i have been playing since stronghold, roughly 10+ years and i know for a fact that the whole appeal to magic is deck building and the learning how to become a better player by becomeing a better deck builder. the learning curve in magic is huge when it comes to deck building and some people are just better at it then others myself i've never been a great deck builder and i cant seem to really win any tournies unless i find myself a "net" deck and just play the hell out of it. but its not as rewarding.

the two biggest hurddles for new players are deck bulding and collection size. there is no way to fix this. as far as making decks "fair" for everyone i dont know the best way other then if you want help with your deck to post it in the fourm, only draw back to that is then ever one knows what your planning on playing. but that does not mean you couldnt pm someone with a deck list and ask them to help.

the best way to get better at magic is to just play games the more the better, and do your studying, go to pdcmagic.com and look at the decks that win. take note of which cards work well being paired together and what i do every morning when i wake up is pick a set and just read each card (i happen to be lucky enough to grap a binder off the shelf to do this) but you can load up mtgo and do it there as well.

well i hate to be long winded and i'll get off my soap box but jmason i really like you idea but it would be too limiting to tell people they can only play certian decks. i think the next round will be classic. and i'm tring to come up with a multi player format and maybe even a way we can draft. cyclops
Back to top Go down
View user profile http://www.inventivewoodworks.com
JMason
Admin
Admin


Posts : 490
Join date : 2008-12-08
Location : Coventry

PostSubject: Re: League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format   Mon Feb 02, 2009 2:02 am

Thank you both for your excellent comments. I'm glad that you all have clear views on the issue of format accessibility, and where the fun is in leagues. It would be good if a few more people could speak up and share their views, then it will be easier to tailor the next league to everyones satisafaction.

With reference to draft, teh pdcmagic site has a draft tool, draftling, that we coyuld use to run drafts.
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Angali
Apprentice Wizard


Posts : 3
Join date : 2008-08-12

PostSubject: Re: League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format   Mon Feb 02, 2009 9:10 am

Hi all

And here's a view from a less experienced player:

I am aware that my decks are not really competitive, and thus I will lose a lot. But then again, also my playing skills are not really competitive, so I would probably lose just as much with a pre-constructed deck.

The important thing, however, is that the deck-building is a big part of the fun for me. Very Happy
And I also enjoy the surprise of seeing what the opponent is playing and what tricks they can pull, that's also part of my learning process...

So, I prefer a format where we can build our own decks.
Or something with drafting, that would surely be exciting!

Angali
Back to top Go down
View user profile
Sponsored content




PostSubject: Re: League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format   

Back to top Go down
 
League 2.2, Pauper Starter Deck format
View previous topic View next topic Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Common Sense :: Organised Activities :: Current League Season :: Previous League Seasons-
Jump to: