Common Sense

Clan Forum
HomePortalFAQSearchMemberlistRegisterLog in
Clan Pages
 About Common Sense
 How to Join
 Trophy Hall
League Season 4
Status: ended
Play Testing
Find play testers and see the play test guantlet here

BYOS Kick-Off
I apologise that this is my first article for three rounds of the league. When I set out the season of eight rounds I imagined I would be able to keep up with the schedule of writing, but no. My free time has been squeezed by other things. Despite that the league is going from strength to strength with large turnouts and high participation. Thank you to everyone who has contributed to our success. I'd like to tell you about a few changes I have planned. First of all I will be clearing out the prize pool by awarding a prize to every single player that registers and plays at least one match in our final event of the year, round 3.8, pauper extended format. After that we will know the identity of the Common Sense League Player of the 2010 (cough** Chris), and I will be awarding a large value prize to that person, and also awarding the Rookie of the year and Participation prizes. The 2011 league season starts in January. There will be fewer full rounds than in 2010 as I feel 8 is too many. Between rounds I want to host some special one day tournaments in formats that don't lend themselves to league play. Commander and Draft are two. The tournaments will be free to enter and pay out league season points as prizes. I hope to have some league assistants by then, so I plan to run euro and usa friendly versions of these.
You might wonder how pauper commander can work, and this is the outline plan so far. The idea of the league is primarily about fun, so I stole the idea of a fun commander scoring system from Armada Games' EDH league. In my commander event you will score points for various goals, and lose points for others, here are some (not all) of the ones I have thought of:
  • Eliminating a single player, +2 points
  • Eliminating a player during another players turn, +1 points
  • Last survivor in the game, +1 points
  • Rare general, -2 points
  • Uncommon general, -1 point
  • Poisoning a player, +2 points
  • Save a player from lethal damage (once per game per opponent), +1 points
  • Be on 100 life or more (once per game), +1 point

Previous rounds
As I said, I missed writing about a few rounds, so I'll take this opportunity to say a few words about what went down.
Round 5 - sealed
This one was so close to being a hit. I wanted to expose the clan to limited play, and knowing that draft was going to be hard to coordinate I steered it down the route of sealed constructed. Except that I didn't control the power level of pools sufficiently, which led to a number of dissapointed recipients of weak pools. The eventual winner, Andymc1, had such a strong pool he only dropped a single match. In future I will try to balance the power level more fairly. One good suggestion was to replace the completely random card pool with a preselected pool of cards, say 400 carefully balanced cards from which random boosters are created. In terms of headcount this round was a howling success, with 22 players, but participation was only around 40% of matches played, maybe due to the cardpool issues. I hate to be critical, but I did feel that some people gave up too easily. Part of sealed is trying different builds, and some people did not do this. Your clan mates are also a great resource, you can ask notable deckbuilders for advice; in fact some of them don't even need to be asked to point out where you might be doing things better :p For reference here is andymc1's winning pool from which I understand he made a mono red beatdown deck ...
Andymc1 Sealed Pool
Creatures 1 Poultice Sliver 1 Razorfoot Griffin 1 Windrider Eel 1 Pawn of Ulamog 1 Moroii 1 Plated Geopede 1 Stone-Seeder Hierophant 1 Western Paladin 1 Magus of the Coffers 1 Roofstalker Wight 1 Simian Spirit Guide 1 Drudge Skeletons 1 Vent Sentinel 1 Sparkmage Apprentice 1 Loxodon Mystic 1 Tattered Drake 1 Darksteel Colossus 1 Saltfield Recluse 1 Illusionary Servant 1 Auriok Glaivemaster 1 Sage Owl 1 Wall of Spears 1 Undead Slayer 1 Stonework Puma 1 Synchronous Sliver 1 Diving Griffin 1 Coalhauler Swine 1 Sulfur Elemental 1 Bog Tatters 1 Arcbound Bruiser 1 Arcbound Hybrid 1 Horned Turtle 1 Chittering Rats 1 Greater Mossdog 1 Moss Monster 1 Emrakul's Hatcher 1 Torpid Moloch 1 Totem-Guide Hartebeest 1 Lurking Informant 1 Trophy Hunter 1 Shock Troops 1 Rushwood Dryad 1 Hedron Scrabbler 1 Lightning Elemental 1 Hunted Dragon 1 Prized Unicorn 1 Dross Golem 1 Revered Dead 1 Venerated Teacher 1 Serra Sphinx 1 Needlepeak Spider 1 Kor Duelist 1 Tanglewalker 1 Vastwood Gorger 1 Serpent Warrior 1 Spitting Sliver 56 cards Other Spells 1 Whispersilk Cloak 1 Chant of Vitu-Ghazi 1 Circle of Protection: Red 1 Brood Birthing 1 Reality Acid 1 Grollub 1 Peel from Reality 1 Rootwater Alligator 1 Spike Weaver 1 Ponder 1 Dead/Gone 1 Mana Tithe 1 Vex 1 Relic Crush 1 Flashfires 1 Flame Slash 1 Sunspring Expedition 1 Scare Tactics 1 Dimir Signet 1 Prophetic Prism 1 Overrun 1 Geth's Grimoire 1 Inquisition of Kozilek 1 Pacifism 1 Dust Corona 1 Rampant Growth 1 Maniacal Rage 1 Curse of Wizardry 1 Shield Mate 1 Eternity Vessel 1 Hunger of the Nim 1 Saltblast 1 See Beyond 1 Culling the Weak 1 Open the Vaults 1 Echoing Ruin 1 Predatory Hunger 1 Distortion Strike 1 Regenerate 1 Demon's Horn 1 Keeper of the Dead 1 Zealots en-Dal 1 Burden of Greed 1 Elven Palisade 1 Inferno Trap 1 Twiddle 1 Lethargy Trap 1 Mind Sludge 1 Glorious Charge 1 Naturalize 1 Nomads' Assembly 1 Lightning Bolt 1 Spire Barrage 1 Pygmy Troll 1 Seismic Strike 1 Volcanic Hammer 1 Robe of Mirrors 1 Mage il-Vec 1 Kor Chant 1 Heat Ray 47 cards Lands 2 Island 1 Mountain 1 Dimir Aqueduct 4 cards Heat Ray
Round 6 - standard format
This round by contrast was a complete success. 80% of matches played with 15 players entered. As always I am humbled by my clan mates. This was the chance of the unknown VictorBike to come out of nowhere and take the laurels. Imagine what the season might have looked like if he'd been there from January to duel with ChrisMH77. VictorBike's deck:
Round 7 - bring your own standard format
This round is almost done, and I'll discuss it more fully in my annual report after December. The one thing to note already is the low participation. Some players have been busy, but I feel this has suffered from the problem that many are not interested in this format. When I come to design next year's schedule I'll be sure to take note of unpopular formats from the past and avoid them.
Round 8 - extended format
Please register for this round, it's an all new extended format since rotation, and there are prizes for all! I'm making an additional plea that you consider playing a beatdown or combo deck since many players have told me they are fed-up duelling control decks all the time.


Discuss in the forums